Simple ways to assess the product An effective writing process should lead to a successful product. A writing product fulfills its communicative intent if it is of appropriate length, is logical and coherent, and has a readable format.
We assessing writing ability improvement the work exercise provides a necessary piece of information that generally confirms our opinions of a candidate, or in some cases, causes us to think about a candidate differently than our initial impressions.
After our initial screening determines whether an applicant has the background and experience that might be a match with our needs, we invite the applicant into our offices for a 40 minute presentation about OPPAGA and to complete a 90 minute work exercise. We believe that this combination is critical; the presentation gives the applicant a chance to get to know us and what we are about, and helps get their minds into thinking about the kind of work we do.
The work exercise is a 4-page case study, adapted from a real life example of a program we reviewed. We use a topic that is not neither technical nor controversial, thus avoiding areas where an applicant may have prior knowledge, preconceived notions or strong convictions.
We set the applicant up in a vacant office with a lap top computer, and ask that they prepare the response on the computer in Microsoft Word.
There are five questions related to the case study that test difference dimensions of the applicant's thinking and skills. For example, there are brainstorming and methodology questions. There is a question asking the applicant to interpret some simple data in a table, and another question asking the applicant to construct a simple table they can construct the table in Word, Excel, or by hand.
Finally, there is an open-ended question that is designed to give them an opportunity to briefly show their writing skill grammar and logic. The overall process of completing the work exercise also gives us a good idea of whether they organize their work to get it done within a limited time, and whether they follow directions.
The writing exercise is mainly valuable as a 2nd opinion on the opinions that we form while reviewing the person's application package or while interviewing a person. A person with minimal training and experience who does a mediocre job on the exercise would be eliminated from further consideration.
However, if an applicant performs much better on the work exercise than we would have expected based upon their experience and training, we will look very closely at that applicant. When a person with relevant training and experience performs worse than we would have expected, it does not eliminate the applicant from consideration, but again causes us to look closely.
We use the work exercise as an alternative to any kind of writing sample. We found no value in writing samples, since we have no control over the conditions in which they are completed.
For a period of time, we tried a group exercise format, in which we would invite 5 or 6 applicants to come in at the same time and discuss a case study together. We abandoned this idea after we realized how much variance in these groups could be created by the particular group of individuals in the group.
The exam practices have changed. Many years ago, the Office used long multiple choice exams as a screening tool. Oral exams were also structured.
Several years ago, the Office changed to requiring some applicants to complete a written, take home case study after their initial interviews. Recently, the Office has developed two sets of exams one for performance and one for financial for applicants to take before they are interviewed.
The exams are given in the Office-applicants have one hour to complete the questions. Interview questions are also becoming more structured and hopefully more consistent among the interviewers. By using the standard written exams, we hope to be able to better identify applicants who have basic analytical and writing skills and will be successful in performing audit work.
Frank LueraCalifornia Bureau of State Audits Our writing assessment is among the fundamental components of our overall hiring process. Because our reports are the bureau's primary products, we look for candidates who possess strong writing skills.
It, therefore, makes sense that we test for these skills. Currently, we only assess candidates who are successful on an initial oral interview.
We issue these candidates a password so that they can complete the writing assessment online. They are given two hours to complete the writing assessment starting from the time they open the writing assessment instructions. We also allow candidates to complete the assessment by fax or at our office, if they prefer.student self-assessment and have them share ideas through mentoring, coaching opportunities, divisional meetings or on a professional learning day.
Making the Most of Student Self-Assessment Ross () has summarized the research on the reliability, validity and utility of self-assessment.
Sure, parents can bring in a handwriting sample from school, (that usually allows me to see their day to day writing as opposed to the “better than average” sample I usually get in the clinic) but I also want to see the child writing in front of me to assess how they create each character.
Essays do not teach a student how to write but they can emphasize the importance of being able to communicate through writing. constant use of essay tests may encourage the knowledgeable but poor writing student to improve his/her writing ability in order to improve performance.
Journal writing can have many different applications based on the goals of the instructor and student. One common use of journal writing is to promote reflection and thought through one-on-one dialogue between the student and instructor.
A Formative Assessment System for Writing Improvement. be able to analyze meter and rhyme.” Our renewed emphasis on establishing each lesson’s purpose rep-.
In the SAIP writing assessment, and year-old girls across Canada scored higher than boys in the same age groups. Why Boys? 5 The evidence of weaker reading and writing skills among boys provided by these and other assessments has become an issue of major concern, since poor literacy skills can have a pro-.